I’m looking forward to visiting the Fullabrook Down wind farm. It should be ready by 2010, provided the plans don’t get scrapped.
The site in North Devon received the go ahead from the government last Tuesday – 22 wind turbines generating around a third of North Devon’s electricity.
Local views
I think most of us will agree that wind farms are no magic bullet. I’ve always considered them to be just part of a larger solution. But wind farms have caused quite a stir in North Devon, as can be seen by the last time I wrote about wind energy.
North Devon is such a beautiful area. It’s my homeland and I love it. I’d hate to see anything ruin it. However, I just can’t relate to the more vocal locals who write in to the papers to spout on about the devastating, horrific things that will happen due to wind turbines. It’s as if these wind turbines getting the green light means the world is going to end.
The letters in the local papers often seem hyperbolic, even vitriolic. They instil an inherent cynicism in me, so I have grown tired of the debates. Of course, that’s my problem and I expect people will pick me out on that. Anyway, I don’t necessarily think the people who write in are stupid, ignorant or even wrong. But I see figures buzzing about their comments that are never backed up with solid sources. I see letters of opinion quoted as evidence. I don’t question the legitimacy of the feelings such letters express, but their weight as factual evidence. Just as I don’t expect my opinions in this very entry to change anybody else’s view, none of what I read against wind farms sways my opinion.
Something I find odd (and frustrating) about the whole wind debate is how seemingly outnumbered I am by people who are strongly against wind energy. The local anti-wind groups seem far more impassioned and more vocal than those of us that are pro-wind energy.
Local consequences
One of the main concerns of locals is the impact of the wind farm on our primary industry; tourism. Quoting Nick Harvey, our local MP, via the North Devon Journal:
Mr Harvey added that the tourist industry is worth £500 million to North Devon and Torridge and any decrease in income would create a whole [sic] in the local economy.
I wish I had the power of foresight to be able to support or play down those concerns, but I don’t. I don’t propone to have the answers.
I’ve commented before that I stop and watch wind turbines if I get the chance. I can remember a few specific times I’ve stopped or wanted to stop when passing a wind farm: there was one farm we passed in Cumbria (Lambrigg); the lone turbine just off the M25 near junction 20 (the Renewable Energy Systems office at Kings Langley); the one at Green Park off the M4 near Reading; the three turbines at Forest Moor; the new farm at Avonmouth, Bristol. Am I the only person who finds wind farms calming and beautiful to watch?
In a previous entry about Batsworthy Cross, I wrote:
At the EcoTech Centre in Swaffham, they have a turbine that you can go up in and see the view from their viewing platform. […] I think such a viewing platform would be a fantastic addition to the area, for example, at a good viewpoint such as Batsworthy Cross.
Viewing platforms could be a great feature at Fullabrook too. One or more turbines with viewing platforms. I’m sure that the views across North Devon would be astounding, and even the most ardent NIMBY would begrudgingly have to take a trip up to the top of one.
How about a centre to teach visitors about leading a more sustainable lifestyle? I think an “eco-centre” would fit well into the ethos and essence of the area. (One of the things I love about North Devon is how localised some things are, especially food. You can get fresh produce from local sources daily and many of the restaurants and pubs are locally sourced.)
Perhaps the Fullabrook Community Fund could contribute towards such developments or help boost tourism in the area in other ways?
I can understand that the development period of the turbines will entail problems for the people who live nearby. I can’t understand people getting put off their annual pilgrimages to North Devon because of a wind farm.
Further reading
- There’s more information and links on Jo’s recent post: Green Light for Devon Wind Farm!
North Devon Journal: Fullabrook wind farm gets the go-ahead(article no longer available)- BBC News item and video: Huge wind farm scheme is approved
- embracewind.com: Turbine Spotting Locations
Your views
Having experienced a barrage of comments about wind energy the last time I blogged about it, I’m tempted to turn comments off for this one – it’s only my opinion after all – but sod it… let the comments flow freely!
4 Responses to “Looking forward to Fullabrook”
I can see a large 23 turbine Wind Farm from our window and it doesn’t really spoil the scenery. Plus there is another privatly owned one a few miles away.
Hey Robert, I’ll have to drop by for a visit next time I’m around your neck of the woods. I’ll bring my camera!
I know wind farms can be really great for green energy and all that, but i don’t see why they have to build it here in Devon, which is such a gorgeous place. IF they built it it would be right near my house and we could see it every time we went down the road, and personally i think it would really spoil the view. Many people walk and ride round this area, and, though it would still be beautiful, it just wouldn’t be right.Apparently you would also be able to see them from Braunton BUrrows, so you wouldn’t even be able to escape them there. THere are many other places to build wind farms in Devon and England, so they should build them somewhere which isn’t as nice as here. HOwever great they are for the environment, i would never ever support them in North Devon.
Thanks for contributing your opinion.
It’s an unfortunate situation that the best places to position wind turbines are on such exposed areas, a fact that brings with it opinions about spoilt views, etc. No matter where wind turbines are proposed, the same issues come up and are discussed all over again, as the to-and-fro in the Gazette and in the Journal shows. Most of the time it ends up a no-win situation.
Talking about how turbines look always makes me think of electricity pylons or telephone lines. I haven’t lived in a time when there haven’t been steel monsters to carry our electricity about the countryside or cables dangling from house to post. It’s not pretty, but they go unnoticed, accepted as part of our environment. And there’s the main problem that wind turbines face: acceptance in what is now such a connected, media-driven world.